Do I Have Borderline Personality Disorder?
Many people who come to see me tell me that they have been diagnosed with borderline personality disorder. Often they wait until trust has been built to reveal this painful event. Most of them find the diagnosis upsetting, and some have spent years wondering whether it is true, what it says about them, and whether it means they will always be too much for the people they love.
There are two reasons the label tends to hurt. The first is that the public picture of borderline personality disorder (BPD) is harsh and, in my view, deeply unfair. The second is harder to say, but it matters: some people with complex trauma really do behave in ways that make their relationships unstable, and they know it. Both of these things can be true at once, and this post is about holding both.
Why the Diagnosis Feels Like an Accusation
In movies, on social media, and in casual conversation, “borderline” has become shorthand for someone manipulative, dramatic, or dangerous to date. The person behind the label rarely appears in that picture: someone who is in enormous pain, who is frightened of being left, and who often grew up in circumstances no child should have to manage.
Unfortunately, the stigma isn’t limited to the general public. BPD has been described as the most stigmatized diagnosis in psychiatry, and a 2022 systematic review found that negative attitudes toward people with BPD remain a problem among mental health professionals themselves. So when someone tells me they were given this diagnosis and felt judged, I take that seriously. They often were.
How I Think About Personality Disorders
As a clinician, I don’t find it very useful to think in terms of personality disorders. The phrase itself suggests that the problem is who you are. In my experience, most of what gets called a personality disorder reflects some kind of childhood trauma—patterns that formed because they helped a child survive an environment that was frightening, chaotic, neglectful, or unpredictable. I prefer to call this complex PTSD, or CPTSD. I should be clear that I use that term more broadly than the official diagnosis of the same name. The official complex PTSD diagnosis requires full PTSD on top of the personality-type difficulties; what I mean is the personality-type difficulties themselves, understood as the result of childhood trauma. I explain the difference in more detail below.
The research supports a strong connection, at least for BPD. A 2020 meta-analysis found that people diagnosed with BPD were about 13 times more likely than people without a mental health diagnosis to report childhood adversity, with emotional abuse and neglect showing the strongest links. Not everyone with the diagnosis reports a difficult childhood, and research can’t fully settle questions of cause and effect. But in my experience, when we look closely—including at the quieter forms of trauma, like emotional neglect, that people often don’t count—the history is usually there.
The personality disorder categories also don’t describe real people very well. Most people have some combination of traits from several categories that doesn’t fit cleanly into any one of them. Even BPD alone is a loose fit: in the American diagnostic manual, a person needs five of nine possible criteria, which means two people can share the diagnosis while having only one symptom in common. For years, one of the most common personality disorder diagnoses clinicians actually gave was the catch-all “not otherwise specified.”
The DSM and the ICD: Two Different Diagnostic Systems
If you have never heard of complex PTSD from a doctor, there is a reason. There are two major diagnostic systems, and they handle personality disorders and complex PTSD quite differently.
The DSM (the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders) is published by the American Psychiatric Association. It is the manual most American therapists and psychiatrists learn from and use when they diagnose. Its current edition includes PTSD and lists borderline as one of ten separate personality disorders. It does not include complex PTSD at all.
The ICD (the International Classification of Diseases) is published by the World Health Organization and is used around the world for all of medicine, not just mental health. Its newest edition, the ICD-11, took effect in 2022, and it has two separate diagnoses that matter here.
The first is personality disorder. The ICD-11 did away with the separate personality disorder types. Instead there is a single diagnosis, rated as mild, moderate, or severe and described by personality traits. Borderline survived only as an optional “pattern” a clinician can add, a compromise reached after considerable debate.
The second is complex PTSD. To receive this diagnosis, a person must have been through an extremely threatening or horrific event or series of events, usually prolonged or repeated and difficult or impossible to escape. They must meet all the requirements for PTSD: reliving the trauma in the present, avoiding reminders of it, and a persistent sense of current threat. On top of that, they must have lasting difficulties in three areas: regulating emotions, a deeply negative sense of themselves, and sustaining relationships and feeling close to others. Those three areas overlap heavily with what would otherwise be called a personality disorder. In effect, the ICD-11 diagnosis describes someone who has both PTSD and something that looks a lot like a personality disorder.
That is a stronger and narrower definition than what I mean when I use the term. Many people whose difficulties grew out of childhood trauma, especially neglect, don’t have PTSD in the formal sense: no vivid intrusive memories or nightmares of specific events, and sometimes no single event to point to at all. What they have looks like the second half of the ICD-11 definition—the patterns in emotion, self-image, and relationships that tend to get called a personality disorder. When I say complex PTSD, I mean those patterns and their roots in childhood, whether or not full PTSD is also present. That broader sense is closer to how Pete Walker writes about it, as you’ll see below.
There is a twist for anyone in the United States. American insurance billing uses codes from an older, American version of the ICD, the ICD-10-CM, and the U.S. has not yet switched to the ICD-11. So in practice, many American clinicians have no official way to record a complex PTSD diagnosis, and the term may be less familiar to them as a result. That does not mean the condition isn’t real. It means the paperwork hasn’t caught up.
What Complex PTSD Looks Like
The psychiatrist Judith Herman proposed the idea of complex PTSD in her 1992 book Trauma and Recovery. She argued that the PTSD diagnosis, built largely around single overwhelming events, didn’t capture what happens to people who endure prolonged, repeated trauma they can’t escape, especially in childhood. Those survivors, she observed, often collected a series of other diagnoses, including borderline personality disorder, that obscured what they had in common.
The writer I find most useful for understanding what this feels like from the inside is the psychotherapist Pete Walker. In his work, complex PTSD grows out of childhood abuse and, very often, emotional neglect—a childhood in which there was no safe adult to turn to for comfort. A few of the features he describes:
- Emotional flashbacks. What Walker calls emotional flashbacks are sudden returns to the feeling-states of childhood—fear, shame, despair, rage—often without any memory attached. They can last anywhere from moments to weeks, and because they feel like the present, they are easy to mistake for an accurate reading of what is happening now.
- Toxic shame. A pervasive sense of being defective, worthless, or contemptible, which can make it very hard to reach out for comfort.
- The inner critic. A harsh internal voice, shaped by how a child was treated, that relentlessly searches for ways you are too much or not enough.
- Fight, flight, freeze, and fawn. Walker describes four survival styles that people with complex PTSD tend to rely on, including the fawn response of appeasing others to stay safe.
- Abandonment. Underneath all of it, in Walker’s account, lies the abandonment depression of a child who was left alone with feelings too big to bear.
If some of this sounds familiar, my posts on subtle signs of trauma and on trauma that looks like other diagnoses go into more of the ways it can show up.
Why Fear of Abandonment So Often Leads to a BPD Diagnosis
The first of the nine DSM criteria for borderline personality disorder is frantic efforts to avoid real or imagined abandonment. Researchers who study how to tell the official complex PTSD diagnosis apart from BPD have found the same thing: in one influential 2014 study, frantic efforts to avoid abandonment were among the strongest markers of the BPD group.
My experience is that fear of abandonment is close to universal in people with complex PTSD, in the broader sense I use the term. It is right at the center of Walker’s account, too. So a person with a history of childhood trauma who is honest about how terrified they are of being left can very easily walk out of an evaluation with a BPD diagnosis, when what they are describing is one of the most common consequences of growing up without reliable comfort.
That fear makes sense. For a young child, being left really is a threat to survival, and a nervous system that learned that lesson early doesn’t simply unlearn it in adulthood. I’ve written more about this in why abandonment feels like a matter of survival.
If You Do Recognize Some of the Stereotypical Behavior
None of this is meant to wave away the behavior people associate with BPD. Some people with complex trauma do lash out, accuse, test, or withdraw in ways that hurt the people closest to them, and many of them feel terrible about it afterward. If that is you, you are not a bad person. But the impact on others is real, and it is worth taking seriously.
In my view, the stereotypical “borderline” behavior happens when someone is so consumed by their own pain that they are, in that moment, unable to consider how the other person feels. Often this is the middle of an emotional flashback: the feelings are coming from the past, but they are being aimed at someone in the present. There is no room left for anyone else’s experience.
Reflect later, and apologize
You can’t always stop this from happening in the moment, and expecting yourself to may just add another layer of shame. What you can do is come back to it later, when you are calmer, and look honestly at what happened. If you were inconsiderate—if you said something cruel, accused someone unfairly, or ignored what they were going through—apologize.
A good apology is specific and brief: what you did, that you understand it hurt, and that you are sorry. It doesn’t need to turn into an extended account of everything wrong with you. For people with toxic shame, apologizing can feel like confirming that they are worthless, and that can make it tempting either to avoid apologizing or to collapse into self-criticism. Neither repairs anything. A simple, sincere apology does, and over time, repair is what makes relationships feel safe enough to survive the hard moments.
Telling people they will abandon you hurts them
This one is important, and it often isn’t obvious from the inside. When you are frightened of being left, it can feel natural to say so in the form of a prediction: You’re going to leave me. Everyone does. I know you’ll get tired of me. It may feel like honesty, or like bracing yourself.
To the person hearing it, though, it is hurtful. It tells them that their loyalty doesn’t count and that you have already decided they are the kind of person who would abandon you. It can feel like being accused of something they haven’t done and don’t intend to do. And over time it can wear down the very relationships you are trying to protect.
The fear itself is worth sharing with people you trust. The difference is in owning it as yours: I’m feeling really scared right now that you’ll leave. I know that’s an old fear, and I’m working on it. That invites closeness instead of putting the other person on trial.
What Helps
Whatever label you have been given, the patterns underneath it can change.
If you have been diagnosed with BPD, you may have been offered dialectical behavior therapy (DBT), which was developed to treat it. DBT is helpful for some people. It teaches concrete skills for tolerating distress, managing intense emotions, and handling conflict. But one client told me that DBT just shows you how to avoid being annoying to other people, rather than how to stop your own suffering. That isn’t entirely true, but there is a lot of truth in it.
EMDR, on the other hand, goes to the root of complex PTSD suffering and heals it. Rather than teaching you to manage the fear, shame, and old conclusions, it works on the memories that keep feeding them, so emotional flashbacks lose their charge. Alongside EMDR, somatic work can help the body tolerate intense feelings, and parts work makes room for the different parts of you that learned to survive in different ways. The relationship with a therapist can also become a place to practice exactly the kind of rupture and repair described above, with someone who won’t leave because you had a hard moment.
If you have been diagnosed with BPD and it doesn’t sit right, it is reasonable to ask the clinician what led to the diagnosis, and to look for someone who will assess your history with trauma in mind. This is the territory of childhood trauma and attachment wounding, and it responds to treatment.
If you are ever in so much pain that you are thinking about hurting yourself or not wanting to be alive, please reach a person. In the U.S. you can call or text 988, the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, at any hour.
I see clients in person at my Upper East Side office, on the border of Carnegie Hill and Yorkville, and virtually across New York State. If you have been carrying a diagnosis that feels like a verdict and you’d like to understand what is really going on, you can read more about my approach to trauma therapy or reach out for a free consultation.
